top of page

Chicken Asado and a Goodnight Kiss

ahayesbirchler
Jul 20, 2023
7 min read

Updated: Aug 3, 2023

TRIGGER WARNING: SEXUAL ASSAULT


After I was sexually assaulted, I made dinner for my assailant. Chicken asado, roasted red peppers, black beans, and a side of guacamole. I would have offered him wine, but he was a recovering alcoholic, two years sober. We chatted about the challenges of raising young kids; the impact it had on our respective marriages. He kissed me goodbye before he left, and I kissed him back.


He hadn’t meant to violate me, we had decided together earlier that night. He was a good guy. Everyone makes mistakes. He just got carried away in the moment. And we liked each other. We were having fun together, before he got a little carried away. He was sorry.


I slept fine that night, truth be told. And the next morning I woke up wondering if I should call the police.


***


I didn’t call the police. The sex had started out consensual. We had shared our most recent STI results – which were pretty recent – and talked about protection. “I have an IUD but I still have a 100% condom use policy,” I told him, “That is one of my non-negotiables.” “Of course,” he agreed.


On a previous date, I had asked him if it was odd to be wearing condoms, after so many years of marriage. “Yes,” he answered without delay. “I’m still getting used to them.” I ran my fingers over his back and smiled sympathetically. “We can always do other things instead,” I said, “But absolutely no sex without a condom.”


That night, I watched him tear open the condom wrapper as he asked me if he could enter me from behind. “Sure,” I cooed, flipping over. In ten minutes or so, he asked if could come inside me as he approached climax, and I said yes, before wondering what was so hot about coming inside the condom? Before I had a chance to say anything, though, he was moaning, followed almost immediately by “Oh shit. Oh shit.” “What’s wrong?” I asked. “I . . . made a mess.” “On the bed? Or on me?” “On you. In you.”


***


When he told me he hadn’t used a condom, I thought he was kidding. We’d discussed my non-negotiable stance on condoms so many times. “Wait, really?” I asked, as I felt wetness between my legs. “Really,” he said, his face blank, his expression unreadable. “I got caught up in the moment.” And yet somehow part of me still thought it was just a mistake. The condom must have broken. Or fallen off. We all make mistakes. Accidents happen. I made him dinner. I kissed him goodnight.


I woke up the next morning knowing what my brain had refused to process the night before. He had made a conscious decision to penetrate me without a condom. He stuck with that choice for the ten minutes or so we were having sex. And then he decided to ride it all the way to end, coming inside me without my knowledge or consent. It wasn’t just an absence of consent, although that would still be a violation. It was a deliberate defiance of my non-consent.


She said I am not allowed to have sex with her without a condom, but I’m going to do it anyway. Because . . . why? Because he wasn’t used to condoms yet? Because it felt better without one? Because he got caught up in a moment? Because it wasn’t that big of a deal? Because he wanted to show me who was in charge? Because it was exciting to violate my consent? Because I was a woman? Because my needs weren’t that important? Because my boundaries weren’t that essential? Because my body, and my autonomy, and my health could be disregarded as trivial? Because he wanted to?


I spent hours the next day at the doctor’s office, staring intensely at the fluorescent lights as she performed internal examinations and invasive STI tests. “I’d like to get on PEP,” I said. “I don’t want to risk the possibility of HIV transmission.“ “Would you like to be on PReP?” she asked without judgement. “I don’t know. I don’t think I need it. I’m religious about condom use. I always use a condom,” I said through gritted teeth with tears forming in my eyes. She looked at me kindly and asked softly, “Did you call the police?” I felt nauseous. I liked him. He was a nice guy. Everyone makes mistakes.


The copays for the examination and the medicines were not trivial, but they were nothing compared to my lost earnings for the day, as I shuffled from doctor’s office to lab to pharmacy. I canceled most my social engagements for the week. I didn’t want to talk about it, but I also didn’t want to not talk about it. I didn’t want to cover it up, like it was some crime I had committed. I didn’t want to be complicit in hiding it or sanitizing it. But I also wasn’t quite ready to be a living PSA yet.


***


I don’t look back at the chicken asado dinner with shock or disgust or regret. I never once said to myself, “I should have read him the riot act and thrown him out immediately.” If anything, I look back and reflect on just how normal my response was.


Of course I made my assailant dinner, and chatted with him, and kissed him goodnight. Because I’m a woman who has been well-conditioned to play nice with others. Try to see things from his point of view. Forgive and forget. Don’t get hysterical. Don’t blow things out of proportion. In fact, it’s best to minimize. Make the hurt as small as possible. Make yourself as small as possible. If you compress it enough, it may disappear entirely. Like it never even happened.


And, oh, feminist that I am, I am not immune to these thoughts, especially as they relate to someone I like. In fact, it is much easier to pretend it never happened. After all, I had an IUD. His STI tests were relatively recent. He had only had three other partners since those tests. He said he practiced safer sex with them. We liked each other; we were having fun. I could just go about my day, get my work done, and later that evening roll my eyes with a girlfriend over a margarita about what a dick move my partner had made. We could just laugh at how selfish men can be sometimes. I could say with conviction, “Well, if he ever does it again, I’m going to end things with him. I’m not putting up with that type of behavior again. But he said he was sorry, so you know . . .”


And besides, it was evident he didn’t think his actions were a very big deal. And it was unclear if “stealthing” – as this practice is called - is even a crime in my state. Perhaps the legal system and he were in agreement: It was just a mistake, everyone makes mistakes. Eat your chicken asado, dear. Kiss him goodnight like a good girl. Don’t make a scene. Don’t get too emotional. Maybe next time you see him you can just remind him that condom use is actually really important to you? Say it gently, when he’s in a good mood, and make sure to smile, so he doesn’t think you’re upset with him.


After all, he doesn’t think the unprotect sex is that big a deal. He’s not going to his doctor’s office or getting on PEP. His mind isn’t racing like windshield wipers between “we like each other; it was a harmless mistake” and “my trusted partner made a deliberate choice to violate my consent and put me in physical danger.” He isn’t unable to focus at work; unable to show up to social events; unable to decide how to talk and not talk about what happened. He isn’t googling the legal codes or precedents related to “sex acts that are a direct violation of consent - but are enacted without force or threat of force - because the victim didn’t even know their consent was being violated at the time.”


***


It’s a devious plot twist; it turns out the heroine was being raped the whole time! And she didn’t even know it! And to make it even more twisty, the villain doesn’t even realize he’s the villain, since there are unlikely to be any consequences for him. He was pardoned by the chicken asado and the goodnight kiss. He has forgiven himself.


Readers: stay tuned for the next chapter, where we find out if our heroine contracted any STIs? Whether she can hold tight to her conviction that what happened was not her fault? That she did not deserve it? That her needs and boundaries do matter, no matter how frequently others minimize, or dismiss, or ignore them? And no spoilers here . . . but by the end of the novel we may find out how long it takes for her to enjoy her sexuality and trust her partners again!


This is a story I am tired of reading. It is a story I am tired of telling. Not just the “stealthing” or the sexual assault. But the story of men who violate the consent of women in all manner of ways; and the women who cook them dinner afterwards. The story of men repeating their own narratives, which conveniently excuse all matter of misbehaviors; and the women who know in their bodies that these narratives are not true. But in their minds they think . . . well, maybe they could be true? Or at least, maybe it’s easiest to pretend they’re true.


Go along to get along. Don’t rock the boat. Don’t get hysterical. Don’t blow things out of proportion. In fact, it’s best to minimize. Make the hurt as small as possible. Make yourself as small as possible. If you compress it enough, it may disappear. Like it never even happened at all.


- July 2023


Update: I did break up with him. I did file a police report. After all the emotional energy that went into that decision and process, I was informed that according to DC legal codes, I did not have the legal right to make my consent to sex conditional upon condom use. Once I consented to sex, my assailant had the legal right to engage in that sex - with or without condoms - no matter what agreement we had made about protection and no matter what the physical or emotional consequences were for me.

Recent Posts

See All
Charlie

May Charlie was funny, confident, empathetic, and open. He looked like an economics professor with his tidy haircut, trim glasses, suit...

 
 
 

Comments


​

©2023. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page