top of page

Charlie

ahayesbirchler
Jul 26, 2023
15 min read

May


Charlie was funny, confident, empathetic, and open. He looked like an economics professor with his tidy haircut, trim glasses, suit jacket, and soft belt. He listened with an interest and intensity that was both encouraging and slightly overwhelming. It seemed like he would never tire of hearing my stories, and I wanted to tell him everything. I wanted to open my entire self to him, offer myself up like a lamb, uncertain if he would make me his beloved pet or lead me to slaughter. I hoped the former, but I was willing to risk the latter. He made me laugh constantly. And he laughed with his whole body, his head bowed, overcome. The laughter was intoxicating; the attention was a drug. On the surface we spoke very calmly and deliberately to one another - all witty banter and intellectual exchanges. We talked of transitions of power in West Africa, drivers of gender and racial inequity, and demographic changes in DC. Neither one of us was looking for anything serious. We discussed our respective interpersonal and sexual interests and boundaries. We were cool and collected; two smart people who had it all under control.


But under the calm and intellectual exterior of our connection, there was a giddiness that would not be contained. I knew by the end of the second date I would fall for him. It was a done deal by the fourth date. I didn’t know what to do with the unsolicited adoration that pulsed through my brain and body in a rush of dopamine, noradrenaline, and oxytocin. We tried calibrating downward; fewer texts, longer breaks between dates, platonic hikes through the woods. It helped a bit, but ultimately it was useless. There was no world where I didn’t end up falling for Charlie. Somewhere between the fifth and sixth date, I gave up the fight. I decided to just adore him, to feel grateful for that adoration, to know I may never have him except on the margins of our lives, yet to adore him anyway. There was no point in fighting it.


June


Ben had penetrating hazel eyes and long lashes, copper hair, and a body that made me take notice. I stole glances while we walked side by side. He knew I was looking; he knew I was impressed. And yet he engaged me primarily intellectually, telling me stories of the asylum cases he prepared for Guatemalan refugees, his travels to Venezuela, his philosophical musings and transcendentalism whims. I seduced him with passing references to Walt Whitman, Mary Oliver, and Oscar Wilde. I told him about my separation, how I had been left alone with a five-month-old and a preschooler months before a global pandemic. “You’ve been through so much,” he said, “I want to make things better for you. Easier.”


And so on our third date, after weeks of increasingly frequent and intense texts, he brought candles and massage oil to my house. He asked me to undress and lie on my bed. “Just relax,” he said, as he started with my feet. He knew about pressure points, pushed hard against them, and instructed me to breathe through the discomfort. The massage turned predictably into sex and, afterwards, we told stories about the respective AIDS clinics where we each volunteered in college.


And then suddenly he said, “You should know, I can go into a dark place sometimes.” “That’s OK. We’ve both been through a lot the last few years” I replied, “But maybe let’s not go into that dark place right after sex?” He smiled but did not relent.


He looked me deep in the eyes and explained that he would leave me one day too; that he always fell deeply into love and then very suddenly out of love. That I should be prepared for that. That at some point down the line, likely without notice, he would be done with me, and he would disappear. Naked and stunned beside him, I asked if he had a timeline for his emotional exodus; if he typically abandoned both friends and lovers so suddenly; if this type of “all in” and then “all out” love worked well for him? Yes, he replied, and his bright hazel eyes were now dark and distant. But he adored me, he followed up warmly as he stroked my still naked body. He hoped I would just enjoy all the amazing conversations and all the amazing sex we would have in whatever unspecified time he allotted us. And so I waited for him to exit my house, I locked the door, and I told him not to call me again.


The day after Ben left me gasping for air, I reached out to Charlie. I gave him the space to say “no”, I warned him I was raw and vulnerable. But when he said he was coming to me anyway, when he extended all the kindness and concern that I so desperately craved, when he said he would treat me gently, I believed him. Charlie never asked me to adore him. He likely would have cautioned me against it if he could have, but he could not. Because it wouldn’t have made any difference. Because he was too delightful, too easy to adore. And because he adored me too, even if he was better at containing it, shelving it, and only taking it down on the margins of his life.


Charlie made the world a fairy tale. There were confessions and blue herons by the river. There were tentative kisses in the woods. There was Andria and Charlie; Charlie and Andria; tipsy with cocktails and desire, holding hands under downtown streetlights as they nearly ran to the nearest hotel, stopping their anticipatory sprint just long enough to kiss at the edge of crosswalk.


He knew how to ask for consent in every moment and in every way, and always waited patiently to see if he would receive it. My whole being glowed when he kissed me. My body responded to his touch like a harp; he played intricate melodies on me. He was the deep end of the pool. And I knew I might drown. There were days when I was overcome with exhaustion as I tried to keep my head above water. There were days I felt like I was going under, gasping for air, my lungs burning; I worried I might be lost forever. And then there were days where I was just so grateful to drown in Charlie - it was so beautiful under that water – so quiet, peaceful, warm, blue light sparkling and shimmering all around me. I was weightless and euphoric, and who needs oxygen anyway?


July


Maybe in some alternate reality, my husband never applied for the Whiskeytown job in California. He got the Casey Tree job in DC instead. We celebrated with take-out Thai food, champagne, and sex. He didn’t love the new job (of course) but he didn’t hate it either. It allowed him to refocus, to see our newborn son, to see me again. Maybe in this version of reality, the pandemic never happened either. We go through the normal ups and downs; at times grateful for one another - laughing as Skyler learns to walk - and at times grumpy – “I need you to take the boys to the playground. I just need a little break.” There is no mediation. No arguing over assets and visitation. There is no bone deep betrayal; no abandonment. We stay married. And sometimes it’s hard, and sometimes it’s lovely. But at all times, it is the life we chose, and the life we built together.


In that reality, I do not lie awake at night with the fear of Ben creeping into my bones. He texted again; I ignored him, of course. I do not lie awake wondering, is Ben a sociopath? Is he unstable? He knows where I live. I do not spend evenings aching for Charlie; it’s been over two weeks since I last saw him. He writes sweet texts that spread a dopey grin from my head to my toes. But he does not have much space for me. Is it enough? Each day that goes on without seeing him, I feel deeper and deeper that is it not enough.


All I meant to say was “Charlie, can we please have a standing date? Once every two weeks is fine. I just need to know when I will see you again.” It was such an easy, pragmatic, logistical thing to say. “Hey, I have kids! You have kids! Scheduling is a nightmare. Let’s just set a standing date.” And then, if I was feeling very, very brave, I might add, “I can’t be a puppy whimpering at your door, Charlie. I can’t wait around, pining for you. I need to know I have a space in your life.”


But I turned to raspberry jello once he was sitting at my kitchen table again after four long weeks away. Blushing red, unsteady inside my own body, all jiggles and nervous vibration as I stuttered through barely coherent sentences. I have no idea what I actually said or how many minutes passed by. Hours? I do remember burying my fire-hot face in my hands on several occasions, as I tried to force myself onward. “It’s just so hard,” I choked, desperate to revert to the flirty intellectual I usually was, yet equally desperate to say what I needed to say. “I have to be careful about the risks I take, and I have to be emotionally honesty, and I have to… feel my feelings. And my feelings for you… I have to be honest about my feelings for you.” Did I ever actually articulate my feelings for him? I have no idea. But I must have eventually said enough that he understood.


“Before I respond, can I hug you?” he asked. I flew into his arms in an instant, leaned my body against him, and buried my head against his chest. He wrapped his arms around me and leaned his chin on the top of my head. I could hear his heartbeat through his shirt. And suddenly I was safe. Vulnerable and safe. I didn’t know what he was going to say to me, how he was going to respond to my tortured confession. But as I felt my whole body relax into his, I knew we were going to be OK.


He finally said out loud all the things I had suspected but not known for certain. Yes, he adored me too. Yes, it was all very complicated. No, neither one of us had been looking for a connection like this. No, we could not entirely explain how or why it had happened. Yes, there were likely to be some challenges ahead. And, true, we might not be able to overcome those challenges. We had to acknowledge it – it was possible that our mutual adoration would not be enough. But faced with a safe off-ramp or a potentially treacherous road ahead, we decided to continue the journey.


August


Every month that passed I felt increasingly certain that on an emotional level, my relationship with Charlie was everything I craved. He made me laugh, he pushed me, he kept me vulnerable and safe. His texts were a bright spot nearly every day. He was a moment of reprieve from my storms.


On a logistical level, however, our relationship was a fucking nightmare. I saw him once in July. Once in August. So much for the Best Summer Ever. Our relationship was relegated almost entirely to texts and, even though just a few lines from him brought me joy, it was so little. I wanted so much more. I wanted regular and dependable dates, playdates with our kids, and dinner parties where we met each other’s friends. When his family experienced a crisis, I wanted to rush over to help with his kids, or the cooking, or the groceries . . . anything to assist someone I cared for so deeply who was going through a hardship that I knew much too well. But I couldn’t. I couldn’t even drop off a sympathy bottle of wine or have a meal delivered to him. I didn’t know his address. I didn’t know his daughters’ names. I was scared to ask too much. I was scared to ask for too much.


I missed him constantly.


September


When it ended, there were no pictures of him to cry over. There were certainly no pictures of us. There were no favorite songs we used to listen to together, no gifts to hold close to my heart, no borrowed t-shirt to sleep in. There was still a bit of Pinot Noir from the bottle he brought over on our last date, but it had soured, so I poured it down the drain. There was still a half-used box of condoms he brought over in June. It seemed like I should have more than booze and sex to remember him by. It seemed like I should have more than a text message to designate the end of something that brought my so much joy, so much hope.


When it ended, it was difficult to mourn in pubic; it was always such a private flirtation. There were no mutual friends; no parties where we might bump into one another. At first, it felt strange to even call it a “break-up.” It was more like, “I’ve decided to stop sleeping with that man I was sleeping with.”


But it feels like a break-up. It aches like a break-up. It sneaks up on me in quiet moments, when my heart plays moments from our dates like a montage . . . all our moments of laughter, and banter, and affection. I lie in bed alone and feel his arms wrapped around me, our naked legs intertwined, as we made plans for a future together: Standing dates. BBQs. Shared parties at our homes. Playdates with the kids. Maybe the kids would eventually ask questions about Daddy’s or Mommy’s “special friend” but maybe that would be OK. In mid-September, we spun out a future together, and we made a plan; we were giddy with hope and optimism.


Yet it was not enough. There are only so many times and so many ways you can ask someone to care for you, even in the moments when you’re not together (which was most of our moments, of course.) There are only so many times you can tell someone, “I need to know when I’m going to see you again, for both logistical reasons and emotional reasons. I’m a single, working mom, Charlie; I plan my days down to the hour. And more importantly, I miss you. It takes the edge off to know when I’ll see you again.” I tried everything I could think of to tell him what I needed, up to and including tongue-in-cheek PowerPoint presentations complete with graphs and diagrams. But by late September – after the PowerPoint, after the promise of standing dates – my texts pleading for a confirmed date still went unanswered. And so I ended it, because what else could I do? There are only so many times you can beg for space in someone’s life, before facing the fact that space does not exist.


When it ends, the loss is not only felt in the present tense, but also the future tense. There will not be shared drinks with mutual friends. There will not be BBQs with the kids. There will not be double dates with my closest friends. There are no more text messages, no more witty or flirty moments lighting up my day. I miss him, I miss him, I miss him.


It is only the past that stays surprisingly pristine, all these beautiful moments we spent together. Every date with him remains ranked among the best of my life. The inside jokes still make me smile, even if it’s a bittersweet smile now. The affection still feels real; the compliments still feel genuine. My best friends get mad at him, “He said he wanted a partner, but he treated you like a fuck buddy. Even after you told him that wasn’t going to work for you.” “He never truly let you in.” They’re right, of course, and that’s why things ended. But beneath that truth, there are other truths.


There is the truth of his head bowed in laughter on our first date, as I described my high school plans to take over Togo. There is the truth of his gentle fingers on my face as he said, “I’m going to kiss you now” on the second date. There is the truth of his voice nearly shaking on the third date as he said, “We will do whatever you want and move at whatever pace your feel comfortable with, Andria. I don’t meet people I like this much often, and I don’t want to fuck this up.” There is the truth of text message exchanges that transformed mundane afternoons into witty, flirty festivals of fun. There is the truth of us open-hearted and vulnerable, as we told each other stories about the fathers who left us, not exactly fuck buddy fodder. There is the truth of the way he not only tolerated but actively celebrated my emotional honesty, encouraged me to vocalize my own wants and needs, even as I asked for more than he was able to give.


Without pictures, or songs, or borrowed clothing, these memories become the only mementos of our relationship. They are delicate, and I handle them carefully, peering over them with both fondness and melancholy in the quiet moments of my life. They may not be much, but they are real, and they remain.


October


I am still waiting for him. I want him to text; I want him to repair what he broke. I want him to say “I’m sorry I hurt you. I’m sorry I fucked up.” I want him to say, “I really did adore you, Andria. I wanted you in my life. I wanted to make space for you. It just kept getting away from me. You’re a working parent, you know how it goes, especially during the pandemic. Life just keeps getting away from us. But I always cared for you. And I should have made that clearer to you.”

I want to know why he left me again. And I don’t want the answer to be “You were not my priority. You were always optional.” I want to hear him whisper in my ear, “I missed you” as I crumple again into his hug. I want him to say, “You matter to me. You were never optional.” I want to sit with him by the river again, this time wrapped in his arms, leaning against him as we watch the water flow by and just enjoy the presence of one another again.


I don’t want to get over him. I don’t want to move on. I don’t want to meet someone else. I don’t want to throw myself into my friends, my kids, my biking, my work, my life that I worked so hard to rebuild. I don’t want to watch as the minutes turn to hours, turn to days, turns to months, and then I realize I haven’t thought about Charlie in ages, I must finally be over him. That is not the goal right now. The goal is being wrapped in him by the river, as he makes it right again. And then we go from there.


Nov


In the end, was he any better than Ben? Was he worse? At least Ben told me that he would leave me suddenly, without warning, that he would be done with me, and I would have no say in it. At least Ben told me I was not safe with him. Charlie told me the opposite – he told me a thousand different times and a thousand different ways that he cared for me, that he wanted to see my good and my bad, that if we transitioned out of a sexual relationship, we would still be good friends, play Scrabble, laugh with one another, get to know each other even better over time (if not quite as intimately.) He made me feel special, and loved, and safe. And then he left me – vanished - just as Ben once promised to do.


I tried dating other people. It helped a bit – flirty distractions. But the first time I was intimate with someone new, all I could think was “Why aren’t you Charlie? Why can’t you just be Charlie?” I didn’t want this new man’s arms around me. I didn’t want to stare deep into his eyes. I just wanted Charlie. And it felt unfair to my date, unfair to myself, unfair to my heart. I decided to stop dating for a while.


With my ex-husband visiting for Thanksgiving, I finally had time to really talk with some girlfriends, and I was surprised to find tears still threatening as I caught them up about my two months without Charlie.


He didn’t completely ghost me. We finally texted a bit right before Thanksgiving, as he declined a party invite, but insisted again that he hoped to see me soon. We caught up a bit, and I engaged politely and formally. Yes, work is going well. How about yours? Still busy? And how are your daughters? But what do you say to someone when you’ve already asked them for an honest discussion of the break-up, and they’ve already declined? They’ve already made it clear in their typical eloquent, soft, gentle language that they are in fact too busy, and you are not their priority. Do you beg? Do you cry, scream, call him every name in the book? Do you retrofit all your memories after all, decide he was misleading you the whole time, decide that you in fact never meant very much to him? And what do you do about the fact you still love him anyway? Where does that love go, now that there is no hope to carry it forward, no destination for it to land in anyway?


He was busy, I know. He was always so busy. But so am I. So is everyone in DC. If he didn’t have space in his life for me, he shouldn’t have suggested otherwise. And I understand he had responsibilities – important ones – demanding work, two very young daughters, a dog, friends around the globe, all of it. But he had responsibilities to me too. He had the responsibility of being direct and honest and transparent, especially once I told him how deeply I care for him, and especially once I told him my back story. He saw me shaking and stuttering as I attempted to choke out my feelings for him in July. He asked why it was so hard to tell him how I felt.


“Caring deeply for men has generally not worked out well for me,” I said dryly. He held me. He told me how much he liked me and spun out visions of family BBQs in our immediate future. In doing so, he took on the responsibility of caring for me too. If it was too much, if he didn’t have the bandwidth, he should not have suggested otherwise. But he did.


Caring deeply for Charlie did not work out well for me. He was careless with my heart, brushed me off as an optional activity that could always be shelved when life got too busy. But I was his responsibility too, and he owed me the truth - spoken in actual words - not implied by actions (or lack thereof.) I emailed him one last “hail Mary” in late November - I miss you, I’m hurt by your absence, and I am having trouble reconciling the time we spent together with the time we’ve now spent apart.


Feb


He never responded. No receipt of email. His text messages stopped entirely – nothing on my birthday, nothing on Christmas, nothing after the coup in Burkina Faso. He was gone. He wasn’t coming back. And he wasn’t even going to tell me . . . it was going to be a silent, passive abandonment. And after everything I’d been through over the past few years, it didn’t feel like Charlie’s disappearance should be the thing to break my heart.


But it did.


- Feb 2022

Recent Posts

See All
Chicken Asado and a Goodnight Kiss

TRIGGER WARNING: SEXUAL ASSAULT After I was sexually assaulted, I made dinner for my assailant. Chicken asado, roasted red peppers, black...

 
 
 

Comments


​

©2023. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page