Fathers Who Leave
I don’t remember the first time my father left. I was only a toddler, too young to form lifelong memories of any sort. I sometimes wonder if my body remembers what it was like to wake up one day with one fewer parent to hug, two fewer arms to wrap around me. Or perhaps the memories live on in the neural pathways of my then forming brain. But my conscious mind knows only what my mother told me: That one evening my father announced he had gotten his old job back and was returning to California the next morning. He expected the family would follow shortly thereafter. He left my mother with a toddler, and a baby, and a house to pack-up on her own.
We had been in Nebraska for a little over a year at the time, and my mother had begun to create a home and a community for us in Lincoln. She believed we would stay in the safe, affordable, little city; she had no interest in returning to the rush and expense of the Bay Area. But what could she do? She was the mother of two young children. She had only part-time work and limited earning potential. She considered staying anyway, refusing to follow, but she knew she wanted a third child and an intact family. So she followed him to California after all, carrying all the weight of the home, and the family, and the grief of goodbye on her still young shoulders. Her third child was born in the Bay Area; her family stayed intact for another decade.
***
My husband left for the first time when our first son was six-months old. It was planned, short-term, and consensual. He interviewed for a job in Georgia four months after I gave birth, and we agreed that if he got the offer he should take it; we would move together. It was not an easy or obvious choice for me. I loved Washington DC, where we met and married. I had purchased a house before we were engaged, worked my way up in the federal government, and developed a community of friends and colleagues that I adored. But my husband had never really settled into the city – he was chronically unhappy at work, made few friends, and dreamed of a life surrounded by nature.
So we agreed it was ‘his turn.’ I would leave my career, my salary, my home, my support network, and move to the woods of Georgia with him, in hopes that he would find what he was looking for in the rural mountains. I would care for our infant son and try to create a new life for myself. We agreed the time was right. We agreed this was fair.
So when he got the call that the job was his, he accepted it immediately. He also accepted a start-date of two weeks later without my knowledge. And so while I led the chorus of congratulations and celebrations, there was an edge of panic in my every move. I had a house to rent out, a job to wind down, friends to say goodbye to, and well-child visits to complete. There was no way I could complete it all in two weeks. So we agreed my husband would move first, check out the job to make sure it was a good fit, and then the baby and I would come one month later.
One month is a long time when you are only six-months old. By the time we moved to Georgia, our son did not recognize his father. And there were times I did not recognize my husband. Who was this man – my previous partner and equal – who left me alone in the woods with a needy infant, no friends, and no family, as he worked long hours and many weekends? Often I also did not recognize myself. In the years prior I had an exciting and stimulating career – I met weekly with ambassadors, foreign ministers, sometimes even heads of state to discuss policy reform and foreign assistance. I wore heels and suits; travelled on a diplomatic passport. And now I was a stay-at-home mom in rural Georgia, keeping up appearances, staying quiet on politics, and desperately trying to make friends at Story Time at the local library. Was this a mistake, I wondered again and again in those first numbing months? Was I right to follow my husband into this new life? Had I given up too much; sacrificed something so elemental about myself that I would not be able to reclaim it, no matter how hard I tried? I wondered.
Over the subsequent year and a half, however, I created a home and a community for myself and my son. I eventually made friends with the other mommies at Story Time and, despite our many differences, I adored them. Our kids played together at the local playgrounds; hiked through the woods on wobbly toddler legs. Much to my surprise and delight, I found remote work as a consultant for clients back in DC, and so my career was not put on the permanent pause that I feared it might be. My tenants paid the rent on time. Friends and family visited our cozy cabin in the Georgian woods. And I began to legitimately enjoy the slower pace of life; the flexibility of consulting; the time spent collecting pinecones with my son; the beauty of the seasons as they unfolded on nature’s canvases.
And then just shy of a year and a half into our Georgia experiment, my husband lost his job. And with it, he lost our employer-provided housing, our health insurance, our only steady source of income, and our reason for being in Georgia in the first place.
***
My mother stayed with my father for almost twenty years. She lived through his bipolar depression, his chronic employment instability, his moods, his awkwardness, his lack of friends. Growing up, I didn’t realize adults could have friends. I thought it was a childhood phenomenon, like trick-or-treating or slip-and-slides. My mother is a warm, social, loving person and yet I remember us being mostly alone as a family. She had three kids to raise, a husband with spotty employment, and the constant weight of my father’s untreated depression. I suppose friends were a luxury that stayed just out of reach for all those years.
***
With nowhere to live, no jobs, and tenants in my DC house, it was not clear where we would go after my husband lost his job. We discussed finding a short-term lease in Georgia, but it was hard to imagine staying now that our reason for relocating was gone. We discussed going back to DC and waiting out our tenant’s lease, but DC seemed prohibitively expensive without either of us having jobs lined up. And so we relied on the generosity of family and moved in to the guest room of my mother-in-law’s house in California.
There are certain assumptions one makes about life. One assumes, for example, if you graduate at the top of your class from a top-ranked masters’ program, make a six-figure salary before you turn thirty, and buy your own house in Washington DC without any assistance, you will never be homeless and never have an uninsured toddler. You assume you will never be in a situation where both you and your husband are unemployed at the same time, living in an in-laws house, draining your savings week by week.
You assume you are going to be OK. You assume you are safe. You should not make these assumptions.
***
We moved to Wisconsin when I was ten. My father’s problematic relationship with work became increasingly unstable as I entered adolescence. I began working part-time before it was technically legal; by high school I was maxing out the number of hours a young teen is allowed to work. I didn’t mind.
But my father’s moods also became increasingly unstable. When my mother finally decided it was time to leave him, I was both sad and relieved. He moved out; we stayed put. He left, this time not of his own volition, and then he spiraled. At the age of fourteen, I found myself in the roles of both therapist and emotional caretaker for my bipolar, rapidly deteriorating father. It did not occur to me that I could say “no.” It did not occur to me that I could ask for help. I was a freshman in high school, and he was my father, and he needed me. He needed me.
As part of the divorce, we all had to see a therapist for one visit. “Do you believe your father might hurt himself?” the therapist asked me. I was alone in the room with her; nowhere to hide, but also no one to hear my answer.
“Yes,” I said. “Yes, I do.”
***
We returned to DC after two months in California. My husband was the first to find a job, but we knew it wouldn’t take me long. The tenants still had six months on their lease; we could not evict them. I arranged a short-term lease in an apartment complex.
For the first few weeks back in DC, I was giddy. I reunited with friends, found a job easily, ate at my favorite restaurants again. We had insurance again; we had our own space again. Our son was back in the daycare from his infancy. We were home. We were safe after all.
But within weeks my husband began to complain about his job. It was boring; it didn’t utilize him well. He didn’t have enough to do, and he used his spare hours to write books. Meanwhile, my new job proved to be exceptionally demanding; so much so that the previous occupant left without any work lined up. She was so burned out she fled to rural Vermont.
“Don’t burn-out,” my new boss told me and then declined all my requests for additional staff. “Self-care is important” others informed me, as I raced from crushing hours at work, to daycare, to bedtime routines. As each day became nothing but a To Do list to complete; a never-ending series of challenges that had to be survived.
“I feel like I’m running on a treadmill at the edge of a cliff,” I told my mother. “If I run as fast as I can, I get nowhere. But if I slow down for even an instant, I will go flying into the abyss.” “I also feel like you haven’t really processed your Georgia trauma,” she added. “Yeah, I’ll add that to my To Do list. Along with self-care and not burning out.”
I gained weight. My blood pressure rose. My thyroid levels decreased. You’re close to being pre-diabetic, my doctor told me. You’re borderline obese, my nutritionist informed me. You have all the symptoms of depression, my therapist said, but I don’t think you have depression. I think you have PTSD. Meanwhile, my husband’s discontent at work continued, and he began applying for jobs around the country again.
The cliff loomed. I just kept running as fast I could.
***
“We need to go to dinner with your father,” my mother said when I came home one day from my freshman year of high school. They had been divorced for almost a year and dinner with both parents was not a common event. “He’s moving back to California tomorrow.”
A lot of my memories of my father are blurry. As adults, my brothers and I sometime exchange childhood anecdotes, and I am startled by those that I have no recollection of at all, despite being present. “Don’t you remember the time we had the picnic, and he got so upset that he began crying and screaming, and then he picked up a whole watermelon and smashed it on the ground? Everyone was staring at us?” they ask. I do not.
But I remember that dinner with flashes of clarity that are uncommon. I remember the exact Chinese restaurant we went to; the exact table where we sat. I remember the dragon on the wall, the lazy susan in the center of the table. I remember how we all behaved as though this was a normal dinner. We ordered dishes to share and spun them around on the lazy susan. We talked about school, we ate potstickers. I don’t think we discussed California much – if at all. No one seemed to think it was important to ask questions like, “Why are you leaving? What will you do when you get there? Will you ever come back?” No one asked “How can you leave your children? Won’t you miss us? Will we ever see you again?”
Our father was leaving, and we ate with chopsticks, and gave reluctant hugs at the end of dinner. And then he was gone again.
***
It was my therapist and my mother who finally helped me to quit my job after a year back in DC. You cannot continue like this, they said. We are worried about you. You are not yourself. You are not recovering. You are not moving forwards. You are stuck in trauma and stress, and it is breaking your body, and it will only get worse if you do not address this. You need to make a change, if not for yourself then for your toddler son, who needs you to be OK.
I quit my job and took two months off. And then I returned to the consulting that had brought me so much joy in Georgia. I faced my fears – what if I can’t find clients; what if I don’t earn enough to pay the mortgage? – and then I thrived. I began biking and swimming regularly, practiced yoga, saw my friends, spent time at eye-level with my preschool son. I found consulting work immediately. My blood pressure went down, I lost weight. I began to feel energized and happy for the first time in years. I was able to step off the treadmill, walk away from the cliff, slow down, and yet still move forward for the first time since our son was born three years prior.
In the midst of my time off, I asked my husband to stop applying for jobs all over the country. “I just need some time to recover, to heal,” I said, “without worrying about a possible massive life change again.” He agreed.
About six months into my stunning recovery, we began discussing having a second child. It had been unthinkable during the period of creating our new life in Georgia; irresponsible during our period of joblessness in California; and impossible during the crushing first year back in DC. The fact that we were even discussing it was testament to the progress made. It was also testament to growth from my husband, who had previously recoiled at the idea of starting from scratch. He was not fond of babies and had missed so much of our son’s infancy and toddlerhood - he spent it hiding in his office, or hiking in the woods, or working on his books. Only once we returned to DC and our son hit preschool did he find his stride as a father. And yet here he was suggesting another baby.
“I want to make sure you’re sure,” I told him. “I will stay on birth control for a few weeks, and if you still want to try then, I’ll get off. You have the right to change your mind at any time, until I’m actually pregnant, which took a few months last time. So let me know if you have second thoughts. I don’t want you to do this unless you actually want to do this.”
He told me again and again that he was sure. And then one evening he mentioned casually, “I have a job interview in Wisconsin.”
I stared at him, mouth half open. “But how do you have an interview? I thought we agreed you weren’t applying for jobs outside of DC for now.”
“Well, if we have a second child, it will be nice to be close to family. Either Wisconsin or California. Don’t you think?”
I wanted to stay in DC. We had agreed to stay in DC for now. I wanted him to listen to me, and respect me when I said I needed a period of stability, when I said I need to recover and to heal and to build a life without worrying it might be torpedoed at any time. But he was still so unhappy at work, and it was true that being near family would make it easier to manage two children, and now that I was consulting I could *technically* work anywhere. I told him he could take the interview.
He did not get the job. Several months later, we did get pregnant. I agreed he could continue applying for jobs in DC, Wisconsin, and California only. I continued consulting, continued to thrive in my newly balanced life, and inside my body our second son grew. At the beginning of my third trimester, my husband informed me he had two job interviews – one in California, one in Arizona – which while technically not near family would be a warm and affordable environment for us to raise our sons, he insisted. We seriously considered both opportunities – researched neighborhoods and daycares, made budgets, and discussed the pros and cons of each job and each city. We poured over cost of living data, perused Zillow and Redfin, read and re-read the job descriptions.
But before we heard whether he received either job, something in me recoiled, shuddered at the idea of starting from scratch again in the months directly before or after giving birth. I was flooded with memories of holding our first son while I called property managers, arranged house showings, and packed boxes. My body tensed at the idea of caring for two children while searching for new doctors, new friends, and new babysitters. I imagined unpacking boxes with a preschooler and an infant, pushing them both in shopping carts through foreign grocery aisles, and doing it all while managing the needs of my DC-based clients remotely.
“Not right now,” I ended up telling him, “I just can’t manage it right now. Give me one year of stability; one year to recover from birth, and get used to being a mother to two, and enjoy the life that I worked so hard to create again here in DC. I need a year.”
He looked me in the eyes and said “Of course. That’s totally reasonable.” And I exhaled. And I felt safe, and loved, and marveled at how far we had come. And inside me, our second son stretched and kicked, and promised he would soon expand our lives and our hearts as much as he had already expanded my belly.
***
My father never made it to California. He made it to Kansas and then turned around. He was back in Wisconsin two days later. He promptly checked himself into a hospital, where we visited him, a visit that was as confusing and disorienting as the Chinese dinner that preceded it. Unlike the dinner, I remember almost nothing of the hospital visit or the events that followed. We were told he was depressed, and he needed some help, and he would be in the hospital for a couple days.
Looking back, I’m struck by how little I remember after his return. Did I block it? Forget about it over the years that followed? Was I just too engaged with my early teen years, making friends in high school, playing on the soccer team, joining stage crew and the school newspaper, working part-time, just living my teenage life in a way that overshadowed the details of my non-custodial father’s life? Or perhaps part of me had already learned not to depend on him, not to get too attached. He was a father who left. You don’t invest in them. You don’t look to them to meet your needs, or offer affection, or return any trust you might extend.
Because so many of my memories of this time are hazy, I don’t know how much later it was when I learned the truth. I do remember I was sitting on my father’s futon, alone, as he spoke on the phone with some unknown stranger. I think I was reading a book, or watching TV, doing something that could be plausibly distracting. I don’t remember the words he used. I don’t remember where my brothers were at the time. All I remember is him telling the unknown stranger that he had attempted suicide immediately before leaving for California (and then turning around.)
I asked no questions. I pretended not to hear. I told no one. I saw my dad less and less often; I have virtually no memories of my dad for the rest of my years in high school. Years later I learned that he had taken enough pills to be unconscious for multiple days, woke up alone in his apartment, decided to go to California, and then reconsidered and decided to check himself into the hospital instead. He survived the suicide attempt; he returned from his journey to California; but none of that mattered from that point onward to me. He was a father who left; he had left too many times; as far as I was concerned he was already gone. Or perhaps it was I who left this time. He faded from my life; he faded from my memories.
And yet sometimes I wonder what my body remembers; how my neural connections formed or altered to make sense of it all. Sometimes I wonder if as an adult I sought out only lovers that would leave me, because my body and brain confused longing, and suffering, and unmet needs for love. How else do I make sense of marrying a man who was always on the edge for leaving me for the next dream job? How else do I explain believing this type of love was worth leaving my life entirely to support his in Georgia? Did I always believe that unless I followed, he would leave me behind? Did I believe that was the way love always worked for me?
We were together for eight years, married for five, and celebrating the recent birth of our second son when I finally got my answer to what would happen if I refused to follow.
***
We were hiking through the woods on our first date night since our second son’s birth, less than two months prior. My pelvis was still sore, and my body ached from sleep deprivation and hours spent nursing a newborn. We hiked slowly, through a lush green August forest, before sitting on an overlook above a winding creek below.
“I have an interview for a job in California,” he told me.
Weeks prior we had engaged in one of the biggest fights of our marriage. With a three-week old baby curled on my chest and a preschooler playing with trucks downstairs, he had once again pushed me on applying for jobs in California. “I need a year,” I told him over and over again,
“One year. Everything else is on the table. You can apply for jobs in DC, you can use our savings to take a six week furlough, or use it to travel and get away from your job for a while. But I please, please give me one year. You agreed to this. I literally just had a baby. Please, please stop pushing me.”
The fight escalated to the point of me shouting, “My entire body feels physically ill every time you talk about moving. We agreed to one year of stability. One year. And yet you keep pushing me and pushing me, after I’ve told you I’m not ready. Not after everything that happened last time I had a baby and moved for your job. If you want to move to California so badly, maybe you should move to California by yourself.”
So why didn’t I push him off the overlook when he admitted he’d applied for this job anyway? Why didn’t I tell him I would divorce him if he ever so much as mentioned a job out of state in the next year? Why did I just cradle my head in my hands and admit defeat, tell him he could take the stupid interview, and just pray that he wouldn’t get the job?
Perhaps because I had already said no so many time; what was the use in saying no again? He had made it clear my boundaries were meaningless; my walls would always crumble. Perhaps because he had been doing this for years; it just felt routine now. Perhaps because I hoped this would be the job that would finally make him happy, and we could go ahead and settle in California, just build that foundation one more time. Perhaps because I was only weeks post-partum, and I did not have the energy or the strength to keep fighting his relentless pushing. I told him he could take the interview.
And when he got the offer days later, what were my options? I could try to say “no”; force him to reject a dream job that he believed would finally, finally make him happy. But where had all my “no”s gotten me so far? And besides, I wanted him to be happy, and to allow me to be happy. I could tell him he could move to California without us – with or without the possibility of us following in the future – and then I would be a single mom supporting two kids on a consultant’s salary in Washington DC. Or I could say “yes” and pretend that I was OK with moving with an infant again, after months of begging for stability, and hope that this time he would not be fired, we would not end up homeless and uninsured, my fledgling life and friendships and community would not be torn apart again.
Over the following four months I wavered between these nightmare scenarios. In the months that should have been spent cooing to my new baby, engaging with his older brother, returning to work after only weeks of unpaid leave, strengthening my body after a year of pregnancy and childbirth and newborn care, I was tasked with intensive marriage counseling, making pro and con lists to decide which of these options would ruin my life the least, renewing business licenses so we could rent out our house again, but simultaneously making budgets to see how much I would need to earn to support two kids in DC by myself. I’m stuck between a rock and a hard place, I told my husband. How could you do this to me? I just had a baby.
My anger was constant; it rocked with me while I soothed the baby at all hours of the night, it walked with me as I dropped my older son off at preschool, it twisted in my body as a form of constant nausea. I made plans to move; I made plans to stay. I worked to fix our marriage; I imagined ending our marriage. “You’ve been so volatile these past few months,” my husband told me without irony as the date of departure grew near.
And I decide to stay. I decided not to follow. He moved to California without us. He left before the kids awoke on a quiet December morning, taking with him our dressers, a bookshelf, a couch, and most the art off our walls. He took our oldest son’s basketball hoop, many of his toys, and all his blankets (for when he visited California.) He took nothing for the baby. Apparently he did not plan on having the baby visit. He left me with white walls, nowhere to put my clothes, a preschooler, and a newborn. He told me he had no choice. “You said I could the interview. You said I could take the job. What can I do now? I already told them yes.”
He complained that I kept too much of the furniture, too many of the household supplies. “I am going to have to spend hundreds of dollars when I get to California,” he spat at me, “I’ll have to get all new cleaning supplies and a new shower curtain.”
As he packed and bemoaned his lack of shower curtain, I cared for our five-month old baby who was fevered with his first ear infection, while simultaneously completing the report that was due to my primary client on the day of my husband’s departure. I tried to stay out of the movers’ way. I watched as he left me and our children. And then I sat in the pre-dawn darkness before the boys awoke and wondered if I would ever feel safe again.
***
My story ends abruptly because my husband left only a couple weeks ago. I do not know how the next chapter plays out. I do not know what this new version of my life entails: the life of a single mother trying to create a safe home for her very your kids, earn enough money to support them in Washington DC, and protect her assets against an angry husband who feels victimized by her decision not to follow.
What I do know is one week after he left, I visited my psychiatrist, and told her about his departure. I told her about my fledgling plans for transitioning to my new life as a single mom to two very young boys. I told her about my mother moving in to help for the interim, my friends volunteering to babysit and sending gift cards to help me refurnish the house. I told her about the four consulting contracts I had lined up. I told her about the mediator I had reached out to help us draft a Separation Agreement. I spoke of prioritizing my health through all this – eating vegetables, drinking water, taking naps when I could, squeezing in occasional exercise.
“Your resilience is phenomenal,” she said in a voice that sounded both awe-struck and sad, “This sort of thing, so soon after having a baby . . . it could fell a tree. You are a case study in resilience.”
And it is true. I am resilient. I survive hard transitions. I build my life anew. I am familiar with fathers who leave. I do not let them destroy me. I wonder if I will look back on this time and be surprised by how hazy the memories of my husband are; how little I remember about the weeks leading up to his departure. I wonder how many more times California will steal fathers away from me. What does the sunshine state have that lures them away again and again? Why do so many of my stories of trauma end with, “And then he left for California?”
She is a new psychiatrist for me. She has not heard my stories. She does not know my trauma. But she is correct, nonetheless. I am resilient in the face of fathers who leave. I’ve had so much practice.
- Jan 2020
Comments